Vacation: In Which I Encounter Someone Going Through HAMP

I was lucky enough to get to the Bay Area over the weekend. There’s a Rosemunde that opened in the Mission right after I left which I am missing out.

I stopped by an old local bar haunt and caught up with some old friends. I was reintroduced to someone I met in passing years ago. He asked me if anything interesting has happened lately and I mentioned not much. Talking with him, he briefly mentioned that “the bank is taking pictures of my house”, and when pushed mentioned that work had dried up for a bit in 2009, and he’s fallen behind in his mortgage payments. He was worried because he had a third child on the way and wanted to get things settled with his bank. He said that he was trying to do a mortgage modification with his bank through “the Obama plan”, by which he meant HAMP.

The funny part is that one of the most interesting thing that had happened to me recently was that I was invited to talk with “senior Treasury officials” and “senior Treasury officials” looked me in the eye and explained to me that HAMP was successful program because it was spreading out foreclosures.

Spreading out foreclosures: what does that mean? It means that the friend of a friend with a third kid on the way really thinks that this modification is going to go through, go permanent, and put him on a stable setting to be current with his mortgage; so rather than stop paying his mortgage or negotiating on harder terms he is going to jump through hoop after hoop to try and stay current and then get put on the street when it is optimal for the banks’ balance sheet. That this negotiation is less about finding a real solution and more about the bank positioning him and his family for the right time to take his “shadow inventory” into their stock of foreclosed homes.

And as if on cue, he said that it’s been almost half a year, and the bank was currently asking for forms he had already sent in multiple times before. Cowardly, I wished him good luck. I know the numbers, and know how unlikely it is that he’ll get to some situation that works out for him (or the likely mortgage holder) instead of servicers or second lien holders.

And I felt terrible, because this guy needs a modified form of bankruptcy where he takes a penalty to set the mortgage to the proper market value, he needs the right to rent his home if he can’t afford the mortgage, or he needs some sort of mechanism to allow him to short sell efficiently. He doesn’t need what he’s going through.

The bar where we were chatting has a sticker of Obama on one of the beer taps that’s been there going back to the primary:

In retrospect, the smartest thing I could have done would have been to encourage him to contact David Dayen, whose series on people’s experiences with HAMP continues (parts five six and seven). Or to check out ProPublica’s excellent reporting on this topic, gathered here on this page. (They also have a mechanism to share stories.)

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Vacation: In Which I Encounter Someone Going Through HAMP

  1. lark says:

    When I read about Treasury and Hamp in the reports from the bloggers meeting, that ended it for me and Obama. Your story here is the flesh and blood version. I actually crossed state lines to work for this guy. What a tool.

  2. Tony says:

    He’s still better than the alternative. We’ll need to win a couple more times before change really takes hold.

  3. S says:

    What is wrong with renting?

    As a parent I could not afford to buy a house until my kids were 3.

    I have two grown daughters, each married with 2 kids. They rent and they work (one of them with 2 min wage jobs and she is lucky to get them, it’s all she could get). Should they be paying taxes to bail out your friend?

    My spouse and I “own” a house with equity. If one of us loses our jobs this house will immediately be on the market. Why should the bank take a loss if our income is not what it was when they made a loan and we cannot state when it will recover?

    Before anybody calls me a raving conservative lunatic I’m actually left of what passes for Dem in the US.

    Your friend could probably rebuild his financial base better by renting for a few yrs, and putting cash in the bank for a substantial downpayment on the next go around. Owning (being a mtg slave) is over-rated. (LOL our AC went out last night and we’re looking at a 10K-12K bill, I’d love to call the landlord and tell him to fix it).

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s